Team ChedesterTeam Chedester
← The Lofty Lender

From the Softball Field to the Closing Table: Sarah Lehman’s Real Estate Story

Team ChedesterOctober 23, 20266 min readThe Lofty Lender
From the Softball Field to the Closing Table: Sarah Lehman’s Real Estate Story

Plenty of people say they want to get into real estate someday. Sarah Lehman didn’t wait for someday. She started her licensing classes while she was still finishing her college softball career.

My guest this week is Sarah Lehman, a rock star agent with Realty ONE Group Impact here in Des Moines. Three and a half years in, Sarah is helping buyers and sellers through some of the biggest moments of their lives, building her own rental portfolio, and proving that being young in this business is no reason to hold back.

Here’s the rundown.

Real Estate Runs in the Family

Sarah grew up around real estate. Her uncle has been a Realtor for 35 to 40 years, and her dad got his license about ten years ago, though he’d been buying rental properties long before that.

Her earliest memory of the family business? When she was about 10, her dad and uncle owned an apartment complex with somewhere between 16 and 24 units. The laundry room had the old coin-operated washers and dryers, and every so often it was Sarah’s day to collect the quarters. She’d walk away with a huge bag of change, probably 200 bucks’ worth. (She kept it all. Her older brother probably deserved a sock full of quarters, but she showed restraint. 😂)

She also remembers the less glamorous side, like cleanouts every August to get the rentals ready for new tenants. That’s real landlord life.

The Best Advice She Got: Just Start

I asked Sarah for the best advice her dad or uncle gave her. Her answer was simple: just start.

Her family never pushed any of the kids into real estate, but they made it clear that you don’t know until you know. And starting doesn’t have to mean selling a house or buying a rental tomorrow. It can mean:

  • Listening to podcasts

  • Reaching out to people in the industry

  • Building real relationships

  • Asking questions so you’re ready when the time comes

Juggling Softball, School, and a Real Estate License

Sarah played softball in college, and between a COVID year and another sport her first year, she earned some extra eligibility. Toward the end, she was mostly in school to finish her softball career with only a few classes left.

She’d watched her dad jump into real estate around her senior year of high school, ride out some crazy markets, and love every minute of it. The two of them are a lot alike, and Sarah always knew she wanted to be her own boss. So she figured, why not start her real estate classes now and see if it works out?

Spoiler: it worked out.

How a Young Agent Earns Trust

Being one of the younger agents in the business, I asked Sarah how she handles the “you’re too young to sell real estate” objection.

She admitted she was nervous at first. Here’s what got her through:

  • Find a mentor. She leaned on people she trusted in her office.

  • Show up. She was in the office four out of five days a week.

  • Shadow other agents. She watched how experienced agents handled real situations.

  • Read and listen. Books and podcasts filled in the gaps.

  • Write that first contract. It’s stressful, but you learn more from doing it once than from anything else. After that, you already know more than the typical first-time homebuyer.

Her broker’s motto? “Fake it till you make it.” Act confident, trust the process, and the confidence follows.

What Softball Taught Her About Real Estate

Sarah still gets her workouts done early, because there’s a good chance a showing or a “we’re thinking about selling” text will pop up later in the day.

But the bigger lessons from softball are patience, timing, and time management. Get the important things done early, do the little things up front, and trust that they’ll pay off. Not everything in real estate happens right away.

Building Her Own Rental Portfolio

When I asked what goal she’s chasing now that she couldn’t have pictured when she started, Sarah didn’t hesitate: building her rental portfolio.

She’s a landlord herself and recently jumped into short-term rentals with an Airbnb. She’s learning a ton and now helps clients who are curious about investing the same way. Over the next year or so, she’d love to add another Airbnb or long-term rental, while staying consistent with her relationships through mailers, events, and meeting new people.

Will she follow her dad and uncle into big apartment buildings? Duplexes are on her radar, but a 20-unit complex sounds a little scary for now. (We’re going to talk more about that one off-air. I’ve got some ideas.)

Quick Picks With Sarah

A few highlights from our rapid-fire round:

  • Morning workout or evening workout? Morning, no question

  • Pregame hype song? Her softball walk-up song was “No Hands,” but she’s going with AC/DC’s “Back in Black”

  • Open concept or separate rooms? Open concept

  • Kitchen island or walk-in pantry? Walk-in pantry... or both, if she can have both

  • Best restaurant in Des Moines? The Huddle, though as a former employee, she says she should have said Wellman’s

  • Coffee order? Iced sugar-free vanilla latte, or pumpkin spice when it’s in season

  • Text or call? Both. She was a texter before real estate, but some things are just easier to call about

  • Early bird or night owl? Night owl

  • Showing day snack? A Bubbler or an Alani, plus a protein bar or pretzels

  • Sweet or savory? Savory (carbs, please)

  • Hosting or attending the party? Attending, though she’s starting to love hosting now that she has the space

  • Dream home feature? A huge walk-in closet with built-ins for her shoes, including a stash of Jordans and the softball cleats she still pulls out for slow pitch

Bonus open house tip from Sarah: people at public open houses won’t touch homemade cookies, but they will grab prepackaged snacks and candy. Agents, take note.

Trending Topic: How to Get Into Real Estate When You Don’t Know Where to Start

If you’re thinking about a career in real estate but have no idea where to begin, Sarah’s advice is straightforward:

  1. Start asking questions. Talk to lenders, brokers, and other agents to see what goes on behind the scenes.

  2. Find a mentor. Get someone you trust in your corner as you get started.

  3. Don’t be afraid to sound dumb. If you don’t know what an FHA loan is, ask. That’s how you learn.

  4. Ask for what you want. Whether it’s business, a friendship, or a relationship, people won’t know you want it unless you ask.

Looking back, the one thing she’d do differently is ask even more questions and ask to shadow even more people.

Connect With Sarah Lehman

Whether you’re buying, selling, or curious about getting into rentals or Airbnbs, Sarah is a great person to have in your corner.

  • Call or text: 319-930-8284

  • Instagram: @sareeee16

  • Brokerage: Realty ONE Group Impact, Des Moines

Listen to the Full Episode

There’s more in the full conversation, including the sock full of quarters debate, the Starbucks drink I’m still mourning, and Sarah’s thoughts on whether you should eat dessert first. Search for The Lofty Lender with #TallMoneyMan wherever fine podcasts are downloaded, and if you’ve got questions about buying your first home or financing an investment property, I’m just a call away at 515-400-3309.